Report: NY solitary confinement conditions ‘inhumane’ (UPDATED)

2

A report by a civil rights group criticizes the conditions of solitary confinement in state prisons, claiming that cutting inmates off from socialization and rehabilitation causes psychological ailments and exacerbates the problems and behaviors that led to the inmates’ punishment.

The report from the New York Civil Liberties Union released today details the psychological impact of solitary confinement not only on inmates but also on their family members, visitors and the corrections officers who oversee them.

“New York’s arbitrary, inhumane and unsafe use of extreme isolation has led to an urgent human rights crisis,” according to the report. “Corrections officials can separate and remove violent or vulnerable prisoners from the general prison population without subjecting them to the punishing physical or psychological deprivation of extreme isolation.”

About 4,500 people are housed in isolated prison cells at any given time, with most concentrated in two prisons: Upstate Correctional Facility in Malone, Franklin County, with 1,040 beds; and Southport Correctional Facility in Pine City, Chemung County. These two prisons alone cost about $76 million to operate annually, the report stated.

Some of these prisoners are alone in a cell, and some are “double celled” — they share a cell with another inmate.

The state prison system last year handed out 13,500 solitary confinement sentences; that’s about one for every four people incarcerated, according to the report. Most were punishments for non-violent offenses; about 16 percent of isolation sentences from 2007 to 2011 were for assault or weapons.

Prisoners suffer chronic depression, severe anxiety and paranoia and exhibit emotional and violent outbursts, the report claims. That includes inmates as young as 16 and those who are over age 65, according to the report, and black inmates are disproportionately assigned to “the box,” a colloquial term for isolated prison cells.

Inmates are assigned to live in such cells because of violations they commit while living within the general prison population. Any such incident is investigated, and the inmates are given a hearing and the opportunity for appeal, said Peter Cutler, spokesman for the state Department of Corrections and Community Supervision.

“In our system, disciplinary segregation, which is how we term it, is a very serious issue,” Cutler said. “When there are individuals in our system, in our custody, who commit offenses inside our facilities, the reason why they are moved to disciplinary segregation is for the safety and security for the entire facility.

“And that’s our paramount responsibility — to maintain the safety and security for everyone,” he said.

The group recommends the state prison system overhaul its practices for separating potentially violent or vulnerable prisoners from the general population and audit its current solitary population to identify inmates who are not appropriately placed.

Read the full report here: Nyclu Boxedin C Reduced

Share.

About Author

2 Comments

  1. Solitary Confinement is out of control. the concept has changed over the years and is now no longer effective behavioral modification tool but rather another means of punishment. Many agencies have forgotten the most important element of segregation placements in maximum custody – no exit strategy to allow those housed there a chance to work their way back down. This criterion does not apply to all but should be in the master plan for those who can earn their way back down to a lesser custody level after two years clear conduct.

    Prolonged isolation creates more problems for the DOC than one can imagine. It promotes violence, mental illness, suicides and other degenerating diseases e.g. MERSA, that add to the costs of incarceration. Segregation is an effective tool if used right.

    Prolonged segregation should be reserved for those who have demonstrated inability to live with others and those that influence prison violence towards staff and other inmates. Once these agencies focus on an exit strategy the state will begin to reduce their costs for such a concept.

  2. Restore Capital Punishment on

    What’s wrong with punishment for recalcitrant, violent, arrogant repeat offenders? Join the real world.