GOP to Cuomo: “You Missed the Mark”

1

In an open letter sent Friday to Gov. Andrew Cuomo, state GOP Chairman Ed Cox criticized the governor’s State of the State address, asking why Cuomo did not focus on mandate relief for local governments and why he pledged government money to stimulate business rather than reforming state tax policies.

“While we were heartened by your pledge not to raise taxes again and to reform our unemployment insurance and workers compensation schemes and our antiquated job training programs, there is still much more to be done to make New York competitive,” he wrote. “Your address missed that mark by a wide margin.”

Cox expressed disappointment, as well, that Cuomo has not taken action on allowing high-volume hydraulic fracturing in New York.

“Your lack of executive action has killed the development of New York’s natural gas reserves, driving this new, high-tech industry – and nearly 60,000 new jobs – into Pennsylvania,” he wrote.

Cox also questioned Cuomo’s education reform proposals, pointing to charter and private schools as examples of educational environments that are successfully providing services such as longer days or years and full-day pre-kindergarten.

“These independent schools are doing a better job at a significantly lower costs,” Cox wrote. “Support, in the form of tax credits or otherwise, for these schools should be on the table.”

Read the full letter below:

An Open Letter to Governor Cuomo

Dear Governor,

New York Republicans listened to your 2013 State of the State address with great interest, eager to hear your plans to strengthen New York’s economy.

Unfortunately, New York is still the tax capital of the Nation, with the highest state debt per capita, the worst-in-the-Nation business climate and poverty and unemployment rates above the national average. Our current state budget contains $4.5 billion in temporary resources, including your temporary tax increase of $2.6 billion.

While we were heartened by your pledge not to raise taxes again and to reform our unemployment insurance and workers compensation schemes and our antiquated job training programs, there is still much more to be done to make New York competitive.

Your address missed that mark by a wide margin. You proposed to use government funds to pick ten venture capital “winners.” When government picks winners, “Solyndras” result. The best way to provide investment capital for fledging companies and to keep successful ones here is to stop taxing capital gains under New York’s punishing ordinary income tax regime.

And since small businesses create most new jobs, where are your proposals to reform that ordinary tax regime? What about proposals to eliminate corporate taxes on our steadily thinning critical mass of increasingly high tech manufacturing companies that are struggling and need capital to survive?

Your lack of executive action has killed the development of New York’s natural gas reserves, driving this new, high-tech industry – and nearly 60,000 new jobs – into Pennsylvania.

Our extraordinary 2009 Republican victories highlighted voters’ frustrations with burgeoning property taxes, and the resulting bipartisan property tax cap put the brakes on rising property taxes. But local governments are still burdened with unfunded state mandates and use reserves or gimmicks to stay within the cap and still provide vital services. Why was your speech silent on unfunded mandate relief?

Charter, parochial and independent schools have been the proving grounds for the K-12 reforms you proposed, but received no mention. New York has the highest per pupil K-12 costs in the Nation, and these independent schools are doing a better job at a significantly lower costs. Support, in the form of tax credits or otherwise, for these schools should be on the table.

You were right to acknowledge that New York has experienced decades of decline. We need to do more than just manage that decline.

To reverse the trend, New York needs a pro-growth job creating agenda first and foremost.

Ed Cox
Chairman, New York Republican State Committee

Share.

About Author

1 Comment