Jury sides with Pataki in sex-offenders trial

1

Former Gov. George Pataki was found not guilty today by a jury in Manhattan after some sex offenders sued him and the state over a program to commit them to mental institutions after they completed their criminal sentences, the Associated Press reported.

In 2005, Pataki as governor instituted a brief program that would put the most serious sexual offenders in civil confinement after their release from prison. Six of the sex offenders sued Pataki and other officials in 2008, claiming their freedoms were breached.

PatakiportraitPataki, the Republican governor from 1995 through 2006, testified in the case.

From the AP story:

The Sexually Violent Predator initiative was a “sham” attempt to “bypass the Constitution,” plaintiffs’ attorney Reza Rezvani said in closing arguments Monday. “You know that the Constitution applies to everybody. … No one is saying don’t lock up the bad guys. But you do it right and you’re fair.”

Pataki’s attorney, Abbe Lowell, told the jury that the most shocking part of the case was “what the plaintiffs did, not what the defendants did.”

At trial, jurors heard testimony of plaintiffs who served lengthy prison sentences for sex assaults on minors and crimes. One, Louis Massei, testified that once he was committed to psychiatric care, he and the other convicts were never given any treatment.

“We were separated from the other patients,” Massei said. “We were treated like ‘the experiment.’”

Pataki testified he authorized evaluations of sex offenders before they were freed as a way to protect the public, not to rob them of liberty. Defense lawyers noted that of the nearly 800 inmates examined, fewer than 200 were committed to mental institutions.

The lawsuit had alleged that Pataki and officials with the Office of Mental Health and Department of Correctional Services conspired to deprive them of their constitutional rights. But the former governor claimed he “didn’t know what law was being used or what particular part of the law was being used” to implement the program, nor did he pay close attention to how it was carried out.

Share.

About Author

1 Comment

  1. HABIBHASAN-An American Storyteller on

    . . . may be Former Governor Pataki had good intentions! But! Sorry to mention that I am a Believer of The Old Testament.

    May be Pataki has his own reasoning for putting he ” Child Molesters” in his Neighborhood but no not me If anyone. Who Commits Crimes Against Children as such I rather ” Draft a Bill that Grants Hanging Till Death” as a Federal Statute in The United States.

    I can’t tolerate Crimes, Particularly Against Children and Women. No Plea Bargains should be ever allowed for sake of curtailing such criminal activities and setting exemplary Punishments Under Laws of The United States and God.

    I really wish I was a US Senator. But! I will one Day.
    HABIBHASAN-An American Storyteller

    HABIBHASAN-An American Storyteller