Astorino seeks to sue HUD over 2012, 2013 community development grants


As he presses a lawsuit over 2011 community development grants, Westchester County Executive Rob Astorino is asking for authorization to sue the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development again over grants from 2012 and 2013.jamesjohnson

The grants, which are set aside for low income communities, have been withheld as the county and HUD fight over the county’s compliance with a 2009 settlement of fair housing complaints. The 2011 grants, more than $7 million worth, have been reallocated to other jurisdictions in the New York metro area but the county is still in federal court fighting the principle of the case.

The Board of Legislators must approve the lawsuit and will consider the request in committee in the coming weeks.

HUD has withheld the grants after rejecting the county’s analysis of zoning in Westchester municipalities as inadequate, saying that the county’s conclusion that there is no exclusionary zoning isn’t supported by the evidence. County Attorney Robert Meehan argued in a letter to the board in support of the authorization request that HUD is acting arbitrarily and is violating a law that says the grants can’t be conditioned on the adoption of a specific law or regulation.

The 2012 grants could be reallocated in the fall when their appropriation expires.

In addition to the $7 million from 2011, the grants total more than $10.5 million for 2012 and 2013 in the Community Development Block Grant program, the HOME Investment Partnership program and the Emergency Solutions Grant program. The county also seeks to challenge the decision to withhold $3 million in Lead Hazard Reduction grants.


About Author


  1. Astorino’s reckless fight with HUD has already cost county taxpayers miilions of dollars. Now he wants the taxpayer to invest in another court battle with the federal government? As millions of more grants–our tax dollars–hang in the balance? Westchester will see the losing end, once again, thanks the Astorino’s selfish ideological posturing. Astorino bellyached when his lawbreaking antics ended up in front of one judge after another, but he’s now ready to roll the dice in court, using taxpayer dollars, rather than resolve a simple dispute with HUD. Clowntime ain’t over yet.

  2. Westchester Voter on

    How is it that HUD has the ability to “punish” Westchester County? Evidently the BOL needs to vote to allow for the suit to move forward. I wholeheartedly agree this should be done. I am hoping that the newly headed BOL can vote to do so in a bipartisan way. I consider HUD’s withdrawal of these grants unfair and illegal punishment for their disagreement over the “proper” analysis of impediments that they wish to see for our fair and affordable housing agreement. How much more will these urban-centric beaurocrats try to do to push their social agenda forward in a County that is clearly multi-cultural? Check the last census figures! And, the CDBG grants HUD has held back hurt our poorest and neediest citizens. Sue them!